For most of my working life, I knew Canada as a peacemaker country that spoke about conflict resolution, human security, and banning landmines. It was one of the most decent countries I knew. I came to think of Canada the way many Indians of my generation did: a decent, distant, faintly dull and cold country that did a lot of good in the world and asked for very little in return. It was content next to a superpower and had a beautiful view of the world.
So the Canada–India rupture of 2023 felt like an unlikely quarrel in an otherwise quiet house of good people. A killing in a Vancouver suburb, an unprecedented accusation against a friendly country on the floor of the Canadian Parliament, and, a little over a year later, both sides sending each other’s diplomats home. Suddenly, India–Canada relations started looking like India–Pakistan relations.
Putting this issue together, I realised how limited and surface-level my own understanding of Canada had always been. The bilateral history is actually older, and the older it gets, the less flattering it becomes. In 1914, the Komagata Maru sat in Vancouver harbour for two months while Canada refused to let its Indian passengers land. Our nuclear history is complicated. The worst part was the 1985 Air India’s Kanishka bombing in which 329 people died, most of them Canadian citizens of Indian origin. It took Canada a quarter of a century to formally acknowledge the bombing as a Canadian tragedy and officially apologise to the victims’ families. Some of this history is inglorious, and this issue has not looked away from it.
An unlikely quarrel in an otherwise quiet house of good people
I think what makes this relationship worth this magazine’s thematic core this month is how quickly the crisis has turned around. High commissioners are back in both capitals. The two Prime Ministers have met, national security advisors are in touch, trade talks are back on the table, and there is a real desire not to lose this relationship—that is the feeling I gathered when I spoke to the two high commissioners. Whether this is a return to the old relationship or something built on a new footing is the question that runs through the issue.
David McKinnon opens our Argument section by asking what has to be built once the reset is done. In our Insight Interviews, I speak to Christopher Cooter, Canada’s High Commissioner to India, and Dinesh K. Patnaik, India’s High Commissioner in Ottawa, who told me that Khalistan should never have become such an important issue between the two countries. Vina Nadjibulla asks the most important question: whether the reset can last?
Beyond Canada, Anil Kumar Chawla writes on the human stakes of India’s maritime diplomacy, Sarabjeet Parmar on the spread of nuclear submarines in the Indo-Pacific, Xie Chao on how China reads India’s role in the Global South, Raj Kumar Sharma on India’s reset in the South Caucasus, and Kevin Zongzhe Li and Armaan Mathur on India’s China competence gap and how to close it. Paul McGarr tells the story of how ping-pong diplomacy brought India and China together.
My personal favourite this time is Nirupama Dutt’s “From Bhangra to Brampton”, a piece about music and homesickness. I also loved reading Ramsha Midhat’s history of Jantar Mantar, a location that has been in the news a lot lately.
Canada is a country most Indians think they know through a cousin working or studying in Brampton or Ottawa. Several of my own relatives are Canadian citizens. But that doesn’t amount to an in-depth understanding of the country. I hope this issue shows how much more there is to it, and how much of it the two countries have to learn about each other.
I hope these two countries continue on the diplomatic high they are on.
Write to me at editor@indiasworld.in

Happymon Jacob